All my life I’ve heard and read two “truisms” that everybody seems to agree with: 1) If something sounds or seems too good to be true, it probably is and 2) There’s no such thing as a free lunch.
That’s all just ducky until you apply it to salvation. Salvation is a free lunch. Okay, let’s clarify that. Salvation is free to us, the believers. Jesus Christ went through torture, death, and hell to purchase salvation for us, but as far as we are concerned in the equation — free lunch. To quote the hymn, Jesus paid it all. We cannot earn, buy, beg, borrow, or steal our salvation. All we can do is freely accept what’s been freely given after being bought at a terrible cost. That fact causes all kinds of problems for many believers, many non-believers, and many non-believers who think they are believers.
The problem is simple. Free salvation sounds too good to be true because, “everybody knows there’s no such thing as a free lunch.”
Salvation is a mystery to me. The Atonement, however, is not. Adam’s original act of passivity sold the newly created humans out to sin. Because of that first wrong choice, we — as a race of people — were utterly damned. I’ll just say that seems unbelievably wrong and unfair to me, but I know “fair” is a place to ride rides, eat cotton candy, and step in monkey poo.
So anyway, Adam managed to insult God — creating a chasm between a holy God and now unholy mankind. God introduced conscience, human government, and eventually The Law with all the ritual sacrifices to keep the idea of the debt man owed Him fresh in our minds. Eventually, Jesus came to earth in the form of an embryo placed inside a virgin, allowing Him to be born without sin’s taint on Him. He then lived a perfect life according to conscience, righteous human government, and The Law. Since He was perfect, sinless, AND Eternal God, His innocent death on the Cross paid our unpayable debt. Salvation? I really don’t know how that works.
In Romans, Paul says:
If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved. For the Scripture says, “Everyone who believes in him will not be put to shame.” For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; for the same Lord is Lord of all, bestowing his riches on all who call on him. For “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.” Romans 10:9-13
Seems simple and straightforward. Come to an understanding in your heart Jesus died and rose again to secure your salvation. Once you have that truth firmly established in your heart, you can say you “believe,” at which point you can “call on the name of the Lord.” Then you are saved.
But how firm and certain does the understanding of Christ’s Atonement have to be? What if you WANT to Believe but you get all twisted? What if you believe as much as you can but still have some doubts? I’ve always been taught God knows every man’s heart, so does that mean He knows if you Believe or not? What if YOU think you believe but God doesn’t?
What if? What if? What if? Ad infinitum! Something very simple gets complicated and I am almost certain I’m overthinking some point somewhere, but I can’t put my finger on exactly WHERE. I know I earnestly want to Believe. I think I DO Believe — most days. On good days anyway.
I know I’m not alone either because so many people are trying to buy that free lunch. I guess it’s natural in a way. You think, “I HAVE to do something! I have to offer God something. There’s no such thing as a free lunch!” So some people knock on doors. Some say rosaries. Some go on the mission field.
Every false teaching at its core is based on “doing something” so God will sell you that free lunch.
But, once again, you can’t buy that lunch. Jesus bought that lunch 2000 years ago and left it on the table for whoever wanted it. So how do you know you’ve accepted the gift? That makes the loop start over again and we are back to trying to “buy” or “earn” salvation, which we can’t do.
Child comes in from playing one Saturday and sits down at the table for lunch. Daddy hands the child a PB&J sandwich and a glass of milk. The child eats the sandwich and drinks the milk. Then he hugs his daddy and if he’s not “too old” for such foolishness, kisses daddy on the cheek and goes back to play. The child doesn’t offer his daddy anything for that sandwich. He doesn’t ask 10,000 questions about that sandwich either.
He doesn’t volunteer for more chores or ask to forfeit his allowance. He doesn’t question where the peanut butter came from or what material the knife was that spread the jelly. All he knows is he was hungry and his daddy fixed him the sandwich and milk and everybody knows when it’s lunchtime and daddy hands you a sandwich and lunch, you sit down, eat and drink, thank daddy then go back out to play until daddy calls you in for supper.
Is that salvation? Just take the grace and go on about our lives? Can we do tons of stuff to try and buy free lunch and end up in Hell OR we can do nothing except take the free lunch and end up in Heaven? So how do we accept the gift and KNOW without doubt we’ve accepted it and been accepted?
I think that is what faith is and I’m not sure I have enough faith. It just sounds too good to be true.